Example 2

Parents decide to take out insurance, including insurance for their children. As part of the application the applicants must disclose medical data. One of the children says no and as a result the application is refused. The parents then use presure on the child and the child decides to say yes. Is that consenual? I don’t think it is. Whilst it is unlikely that a 4 year old will be able to make a informed choice, what about a 14 year old? 14 year olds can make life changing choices, so why can they be forced to realease data? If there is something they don’t want their parents or others to know, then they don’t have much chance of keeping it from them and should they be forced to tell others? Don’t chiildren have rights?If the parents want to make a claim for an injury but the child refuses to allow the GP to release some info and again parents apply pressure getting the child to change their minds and say yes, is that consenual?What if it was a case of a man/womans partner wanting the other to share data? Saying no to this could cause a breakdown in the relationship, which could involve children. Is that consensual?

What about children being lead to think that telling insurance compaines and evrybody else, such as employers is normal because that is what they have been lead to belive. I know this is a phylisophical question, but it is something that I have felt needs to be considered by doctors as they are often the only people standing in the way of people gaing access to our records (although with the new natuional databse, something that is to be removed with the introduction of a national database (it is interesteing to note that children seem to have been excluded from the national databases that ministers and doctors cliam will save lives and saying no will cause harm to pateints).